5 Best Roof Replacement Contractors in Toledo, OH (2026)

A roof replacement is a five-figure decision most homeowners make once or twice in a lifetime, and Toledo’s mix of lake-effect snow, spring hail, and freeze-thaw winters is unforgiving of a bad install. Picking a contractor on price alone tends to backfire in year three, not year one, when the cheap flashing starts leaking. This guide ranks the five roof replacement contractors Toledo homeowners actually hire, based on manufacturer certification, real local track record, and what happens after the crew leaves.

Roofing419 delivers expert roofing services for homeowners in and around Toledo Ohio.

1. Roofing419 — Toledo Roofing Company

Roofing419 – Toledo Roofing Company Logo

Address: 1640 Coining Dr, Toledo OH 43612 | Phone: (419) 509-0456

Roofing419 has handled residential roof replacement across Lucas County for over 10 years and holds top-tier manufacturer certifications from two shingle brands, along with Roser certification for metal roofing. That puts it among the few Toledo contractors certified at the top tier by two shingle manufacturers and a metal roofing manufacturer at the same time.

Every job starts with a free 19-point inspection, photos included, before any pricing conversation. Replacements go through a full tear-off to bare decking, ice and water barrier at eaves and valleys, and a complete manufacturer-matched roofing system rather than mixed components. Roofing419’s Roser certification also qualifies homeowners for the full 50-year manufacturer warranty on metal roof replacement. Awards include the Best of Toledo Award for nine consecutive years (2017 to 2025), the Marketplace Ethics Award in 2016 and 2023, and a Top 3 Roofing Contractors Toledo Ohio placement for 2025.

Best for: Homeowners who want the most certified roof replacement contractor in Toledo and a documented inspection process from estimate through final walk-through.

2. Pro Craft Home Products

Address: 1622 Coining Dr, Toledo OH 43612 | Phone: 419-475-9600

Pro Craft has worked in Northwest Ohio since 1952, over 70 years under the same family ownership. The company has held Owens Corning Platinum Preferred status since 2019, carries an A+ BBB rating, and holds both Roser Certified and Decra Partner in Quality credentials for metal roofing. Beyond roof replacement, Pro Craft also handles siding, gutters, windows, and attic insulation, which suits homeowners who want one contractor for a full exterior project rather than roofing alone.

Best for: Homeowners who want the longest local track record and a single contractor for roofing plus the rest of the exterior.

3. Erie Home

Headquartered in Toledo, Erie Home operates under several branded names, including Erie Construction and Erie Metal Roofs, and has grown into one of the larger roofing contractors serving homeowners well beyond Ohio. Its core specialty is stone-coated steel roofing, with product lines styled to resemble dimensional asphalt shingles, Spanish clay tile, and wood shake, marketed as a longer-lasting alternative to traditional materials. Beyond roofing, the contractor also offers basement waterproofing and foundation repair, making it more of a broader exterior and structural remodeling business than a roofing-only outfit. In-house financing is available to spread out project costs, and the sales process typically involves an in-home visit where pricing is presented and negotiated on the spot. Homeowner feedback is mixed on that part of the experience, with some reviewers describing a sales-heavy pitch and shifting quotes during the visit, so it’s worth comparing numbers independently before signing.

Best for: Metal/stone-coated steel roofing with financing options for homeowners who want to spread out a larger project cost.

4. Integrity Home Exteriors

Based in Toledo, Integrity Home Exteriors positions itself as a full exterior remodeling contractor rather than a roofing specialist, with roofing, window, and siding installation offered as core service lines across the Toledo and Detroit metro areas. It has built a long-standing regional presence and shows up frequently among the more established names on homeowner-matching platforms in the area. Reviewers tend to highlight professionalism and clear communication from the crews sent out for estimates and installs, describing the process as informative and well explained. Because roofing is one of several service lines rather than the sole focus, project timelines and crew specialization can vary depending on which type of job is booked.

Best for: Homeowners bundling roofing with windows or siding into one project.

5. Great Lakes Home Remodeling

Great Lakes Home Remodeling serves homeowners across Ohio, Michigan, and Indiana, with a focus on stone-coated metal roofing systems alongside more traditional architectural fiberglass shingle options. The contractor markets itself as a one-stop exterior remodeler, also handling insulated siding installation for homeowners looking to combine roofing and siding work into a single project. Financing is available for qualifying jobs, which tends to matter more here given the higher material cost of metal roofing compared to asphalt shingles. Its service area spanning three states points to a larger regional operation rather than a single-market, hyper-local contractor.

Best for: Stone-coated metal roofing paired with siding in a single exterior remodel.

Which Roofing Companies Are Best for Metal Roof Installation in Toledo?

Not every certified shingle installer is certified for metal. Metal roofing runs on its own manufacturer credential, separate from Owens Corning or CertainTeed shingle certifications. In Toledo, Roofing419 and Pro Craft Home Products both hold Roser Certified Installer status, and Pro Craft additionally holds Decra Partner in Quality certification for stone-coated steel systems. That certification is what qualifies homeowners for the full 50-year manufacturer warranty on standing seam and stone-coated steel, coverage a non-certified installer can’t offer regardless of the materials used. If a metal roof is on the table, ask specifically which metal certification a contractor holds before assuming shingle credentials carry over.

Best Roof Replacement Contractors for Toledo’s Harsh Winters

Toledo sits close enough to Lake Erie to get real lake-effect snow and dozens of freeze-thaw cycles every winter, conditions that punish a roof built with builder-grade materials or a rushed install. The contractors best suited to that climate are the ones installing full manufacturer systems (not mixed-brand components), checking attic ventilation as part of the process, and using ice and water barrier at eaves and valleys where ice dams form. Roofing419 build to this standard as part of their certification requirements, not as an upsell.

How Much Does a Roof Replacement Cost in Toledo, OH? (2026)

The Roofing419 crew delivering quality roofing work for Toledo homeowners.

These are general ranges, not a quote. Actual price depends on roof size, pitch, decking condition once tear-off exposes it, material grade, and how many layers need removing. Architectural shingles cost roughly 20 to 30% more than 3-tab but hold up better against Toledo’s wind and freeze-thaw cycles, which is why most contractors here recommend them over 3-tab for anything beyond the cheapest tier. Permits in Lucas County typically run $150 to $400 and should be included in any reputable contractor’s process, not billed as a surprise add-on.

Get written, itemized estimates from at least two or three roofing contractors covering the same scope and material grade before deciding. A quote given without an on-site inspection is a guess, not a price.

Roof Replacement Financing in Toledo, OH

Most established Toledo roofing contractors offer financing for qualified homeowners, typically structured as monthly payments rather than requiring the full cost upfront. Roofing419 offers financing options starting as low as $99 a month for qualified applicants. Ask any contractor for the specific terms in writing, interest rate, term length, and whether there’s a penalty for paying it off early, before signing.

The Roof Replacement Process in Toledo, OH

A full roof replacement generally follows the same sequence regardless of contractor, though the quality of each step varies:

1. Free inspection and written estimate. A real inspection includes photos and a specific material and cost breakdown, not a verbal ballpark.
2. Permit filing. Lucas County requires a permit for full roof replacement. A licensed contractor pulls this before work starts.
3. Tear-off. Old roofing comes off down to bare decking so the crew can check for rot or soft spots underneath.
4. Decking repair. Any compromised decking gets replaced before new material goes down, this step gets skipped by corner-cutting crews and causes problems within a few years.
5. Underlayment and ice barrier. Synthetic underlayment plus ice and water shield at eaves and valleys, where Toledo’s freeze-thaw cycles cause the most damage.
6. Flashing, drip edge, and shingles or metal panels. Installed as a complete manufacturer system rather than mixed components, which matters for warranty coverage.
7. Ventilation check. Proper attic airflow is the single biggest factor in how long a Toledo roof actually lasts.
8. Cleanup and final walk-through. Debris removal, a magnetic sweep for nails, and a walk-through with the homeowner before the job is considered done.

How Long Does a Roof Replacement Take in Toledo, OH?

Most single-family homes take one to two days from tear-off to cleanup once work begins. Larger homes, steep or complex rooflines, or metal roofing systems can take three to four days. Weather delays are common in Toledo, an experienced contractor builds that into the schedule rather than rushing the job to hit a date.

Is It Cheaper to Repair or Replace a Roof in Toledo?

Repair generally makes sense if the roof is under 15 years old, the damage is isolated to under 30% of the surface, and there’s no widespread decking damage. Replacement is the better long-term move if the roof is 20 years or older, has multiple leak sources, or is already on a second layer of shingles. A patch job on a roof that actually needs replacing tends to cost more over time than replacing it once, since the same trouble spots keep reopening.